Bento gets a makeover

(warpstreamlabs.github.io)

13 points | by ordinarily 3 days ago ago

11 comments

  • atombender 3 days ago ago

    Anyone using Bento rather than the original Benthos, now Redpanda Connect?

    From GitHub it seems Bento isn't anywhere near as active as Benthos/Redpanda.

    Meanwhile, there's Wombat, the open source fork made by Synadia, makers of NATS; that project looks pretty dead.

    • kentm 2 days ago ago

      Personally, I was eyeing redpanda connect for some use cases and the telemetry was a huge turnoff, even if it’s disabled. This is in addition to the licensing schemes. So my focus has been on Bento instead.

    • mdaniel 3 days ago ago

      > the open source fork made by Synadia, makers of NATS

      Well there's an anti-endorsement if I've seen one

    • ordinarily 3 days ago ago

      Pretty good community, Slack has 600+ users.

  • rekwah 3 days ago ago

    I'm fine with forks but hard to see @jeffail's marketing/persona of Benthos forked too. It was quirky, to say the least. Difficult line to walk, forking code brings repo docs but it feels insincere reading not on the original.

    • jeffail 3 days ago ago

      Personally, I'm happy to see them evolving it with my juices left intact. When we transitioned benthos.dev to https://docs.redpanda.com/redpanda-connect we gained a much larger (and more competent) docs team, but as a consequence had to trim a lot of the old personality. I don't regret the transition but I do take a bit of comfort seeing the WarpStream peeps continue to have fun with it.

      It's like shedding an almost intact full body skin and finding comfort in watching colleagues take it bowling, having a great time.

      • ordinarily 3 days ago ago

        Was hoping you'd appreciate our efforts to retain your original quirky vision. We named the rice ball Geoff as a homage to you (intentionally spelled the silly way). (https://warpstreamlabs.github.io/bento/docs/about)/

        • ralferoo 2 days ago ago

          FWIW in the UK, Geoff is the usual spelling (from Geoffrey) of the name. Jeff (from Jeffrey) also exists in the UK, but is much rarer, even if it's the most common form in the US.

  • DidYaWipe 3 days ago ago

    A makeover? This isn't the original Bento at all.

    https://dbservices.com/blog/filemaker-ends-support-for-bento

    • ordinarily 3 days ago ago

      Lol I was actually looking at the Wiki earlier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bento_(database)

      • DidYaWipe 2 days ago ago

        Back when Apple Notes was useless because it lacked categories, folders, or any other way to ORGANIZE your notes... I turned to Bento.

        I can't remember if I liked it or hated it. Probably the latter, since I haven't used it since well before it was discontinued.